This article reruns a 2023 benchmark with the latest LLMs, comparing direct SQL generation against querying through a structured dbt Semantic Layer. It finds that while text-to-SQL accuracy has jumped, a modeled Semantic Layer still delivers near-perfect, deterministic results for covered queries, making it ideal for complex or critical use cases.

The article discusses the shortcomings of achieving high accuracy in Text-to-SQL systems, emphasizing that 90% accuracy is insufficient for enterprise applications. It highlights the need for rigorous evaluation frameworks, like Spider 2.0, to ensure reliability and trust in AI-driven analytics.