Obama's Book Club Reveals His Liberal Worldview
Sam Adler-Bell reviews Obama's six-part Audible podcast "A Great Book with Barack Obama," arguing the book picks expose a tragic, ambivalent liberalism that prizes complexity and avoids firm moral judgment. He says that habit becomes an alibi, most visibly when Obama talks about Israel-Palestine and his own presidency.
- The podcast's book choices (Gilead, All the King's Men, Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy, The Fire Next Time) reveal Obama's core themes: pragmatism, humility about human nature, and reforming institutions from within.
- Adler-Bell says Obama's "it's complicated" stance, and his faith that "better is good," works as an alibi that lets him avoid harder judgments, especially on Gaza and Israel.
- In his conversation with Ta-Nehisi Coates, Obama's answers about his presidency and his "ghosts" stay qualified, and Adler-Bell reads his framing of his own failures as tragedy rather than real accountability.
Sam Adler-Bell's New York Magazine piece treats Obama's six-part Audible podcast, "A Great Book with Barack Obama," as a window onto the worldview of the liberal establishment he embodies. The series, from Audible and the Obamas' Higher Ground, pairs Obama with guests like Tom Hanks, Jill Lepore, Lauren Groff, Ta-Nehisi Coates, Percival Everett, and Ben Rhodes, each discussing a book that shaped how Obama sees the world. Adler-Bell's opening framing is a riff on Obama's October 24 Cleveland remark that the White House looked like "Saddam Hussein opened a Cheesecake Factory," which he reads as a jab at Trump's gaudy taste that also, incidentally, caught some ordinary Trump supporters. His broader argument is that Obama and Trump are mirror images: each one is an authentic cultural stand-in for his base, one with dad rock and well-reviewed fiction, the other with fast food and television.
On the podcast itself, Adler-Bell is more generous than you might expect. He calls it far livelier than Obama's earlier six-hour conversation with Bruce Springsteen, which he found stultifying. The best exchanges are the ones where Obama draws out specific ideas: Marilynne Robinson's *Gilead* prompting reflections on fatherhood and faith, Warren's *All the King's Men* leading to a discussion of Huey Long and populism, and Obama's quote about how he learned voters want stories about their own lives rather than ten-point plans. Adler-Bell also identifies the recurring Obama themes: the struggle to keep one's humanity inside large, amoral systems, skepticism about male grandiosity, reform from within, and a Niebuhrian blend of national optimism with pessimism about human nature. The Willie Stark passage from *All the King's Men*, about needing to make goodness out of badness, becomes the emblem of his politics.
Where the piece turns sharp is on the Rhodes conversation about le Carré's *Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy*. Adler-Bell says the two men seem dumbfounded and defensive about their roles running the national-security state, and that the dialogue slides from thrilling to banal, reducing the novel to a case for "muddling through." He notes Michelle Obama appears throughout as the moral conscience in her husband's reading lists, and he suggests the whole project reflects a liberalism that is earnest, literate, and morally anguished but short on accountability for its own record. He is careful to say that the podcast will be a balm for listeners who appreciate a president with an inner life, and that this is exactly the sensibility he expects to make a comeback after the Democrats' midterm win.