Amanda Seyfried on Joining Nathan Fielder's Elizabeth Holmes Documentary

Open original

This Rolling Stone interview has Amanda Seyfried, Nathan Fielder, and Lance Oppenheim talking through how Seyfried ended up re-creating Elizabeth Holmes in "You Can See Everything," a documentary that embeds the filmmakers with Holmes and her partner Billy Evans before her prison sentence. The conversation covers how the project came together, the risks Seyfried took without a contract in place, and why the final cut is so disorienting.

  • Seyfried agreed to a 30-minute Zoom and let the crew into her apartment with no talent reps or protections, then had her deal retroactively set up by her lawyer once the reenactments began.
  • She had no creative control or approval over the re-creations, and was filmed meeting Billy Evans while the filmmakers were recording him in his own home.
  • The filmmakers say they edited toward the moments they disagreed on most, and Fielder's editor doubted that watching all 700 hours would change the conclusions a viewer reaches from the three-hour film.

Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim's documentary "You Can See Everything" follows Fielder embedding himself in the home of Elizabeth Holmes, the Theranos founder convicted of fraud, and her partner Billy Evans just before she reports to prison. The film's second half adds a twist: Amanda Seyfried, who played Holmes in the Hulu series "The Dropout," appears in reenactments with Holmes's own mannerisms, a secret the filmmakers kept until release. This Rolling Stone interview is Seyfried's first on-the-record discussion of the project, and it covers how she got involved, what the experience was like, and how the team has processed the fallout. Seyfried explains that the project started as a request for a 30-minute Zoom. Fielder got her number through Emma Stone, and the pitch was simple: come over, watch the first half of the footage, and talk about it. Seyfried agreed, and she had just returned from the Venice Film Festival, so she said yes without talking to her agent or lawyer. Her team had to retroactively set up protections once cameras were already in her apartment. Fielder and Oppenheim tried to expand the circle of collaborators, but many people they approached refused to be on camera because of Holmes's toxic reputation. Holmes's parents, according to Fielder, felt that "The Dropout" was the main way the public understood who Holmes was, which is why the team wanted Seyfried's perspective. The most revealing part of the conversation is about the performance itself. Seyfried says she built her Holmes from the roughly 10 hours of deposition tapes, not from the Nightline or 60 Minutes footage, because Holmes was consistent and present in those recordings. Years later, watching herself and Holmes on screen, she found she still tilted her head the same way. Seyfried says the process felt dangerous, that she wanted answers about who was pulling the strings, and that she has no regrets. Oppenheim describes the experience as having "made my brain and body feel on fire," though the interview is cut short before the team fully weighs in on that.

Ask about this article