The 'You Can See Everything' Interview You've Been Waiting For
This Rolling Stone interview has Amanda Seyfried, Nathan Fielder, and Lance Oppenheim talking for the first time about "You Can See Everything," the documentary where Seyfried appears in re-created scenes playing Elizabeth Holmes. They cover how she was pulled into the project and how much control she had over it.
- Seyfried agreed to a short meeting and a look at footage, not to act, and says she had no creative approval over the re-creations she ended up filming.
- Her lawyer had to retroactively set up her deal after she had already committed, which she describes as far from the normal process.
- Seyfried says her Holmes performance in The Dropout is still locked into her muscle memory, which is why she slipped back into the character on camera.
Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim made "You Can See Everything," a documentary that embeds Fielder in the home of Elizabeth Holmes and her partner Billy Evans just before Holmes reported to prison for fraud. The film's biggest twist, and the reason it has drawn so much attention, is that Amanda Seyfried, who played Holmes in the Hulu series The Dropout, shows up in the second half to re-create scenes with Fielder. Rolling Stone talked to all three about the project, and Seyfried was speaking publicly about it for the first time. The piece is built around that Zoom conversation, with the three of them picking apart how Seyfried got pulled in and what the experience did to them.
The origin story is less calculated than the finished film makes it look. Fielder says the team struggled to expand beyond the original house footage because Holmes carried such a toxic reputation that few people wanted to appear on camera. Holmes's parents had strong views about The Dropout, which they saw as the main way the public understood their daughter, so the team reached out to Seyfried. Emma Stone supplied the phone number. Seyfried agreed after a 30-minute Zoom, with no agent or lawyer involved, to let the crew come to her New York apartment and watch footage with her. She had just returned from the Venice Film Festival and assumed it would be a conversation about her research for the role. Her lawyer later had to retroactively set up a deal once the re-creations became part of the plan. Seyfried admits she felt some risk, though not enough to stop her, and she describes the trust she gave them as strange and fast.
The re-creation idea came out of those apartment sessions. Seyfried began imitating Holmes on camera, including the head tilt and stare she developed while playing her, and both Fielder and Oppenheim sensed she had unfinished business with the character. Seyfried says the 10 hours of Holmes's deposition tapes were what locked the performance into her muscle memory, more than her television interviews. Fielder says that sitting across from her in these staged moments made him realize how well he had come to understand Holmes's habits. The three describe the process as emotionally punishing, with Oppenheim saying it left him feeling like his brain and body were on fire. Seyfried says she has no regrets and is enjoying the attention, even as the film's ambiguity about who is manipulating whom keeps the audience guessing.