Wink of an Eye - Wikipedia
This is the Wikipedia entry for a 1968 Star Trek: The Original Series episode in which hyperaccelerated aliens invade the Enterprise to abduct the crew as breeding stock. It covers the plot, production credits, and critical reception, which is mostly unkind to the episode's science.
- Critics Dayton Ward, David Alan Mack, and Zack Handlen all say the concept is clever but falls apart on closer look, with Handlen grading it a B−.
- Melissa Hayes-Gehrke of the University of Maryland argues the phaser scene is physically impossible, since a beam moving at light speed can't be dodged by a slowed-down target.
- Ward does praise the set design, especially the lighting and tilted camera angles that sell the hyperaccelerated movement.
"Wink of an Eye" is season 3, episode 11 of the original Star Trek, first aired November 29, 1968. Arthur Heinemann wrote the teleplay from a story by Gene L. Coon, who used the pen name Lee Cronin, and Jud Taylor directed. The plot: the Enterprise answers a distress call at Scalos, a city that looks empty except for an insect-like buzzing. Crewman Compton vanishes in front of Dr. McCoy, and soon the ship starts malfunctioning because of a mysterious device attached to life support. Kirk gets put into hyperacceleration after drinking coffee, which makes him invisible to his crew while letting him perceive the Scalosians, who move so fast they're nearly undetectable.
The Scalosians are led by Queen Deela, played by Kathie Browne, and their scientist Rael, played by Jason Evers. Their plan is to use the Enterprise as a cryogenic storage unit and take the crew as breeding stock, since their own men were made sterile by a natural disaster that also caused their accelerated state. Kirk tries to bargain, and then tries to stun Deela, only to find that the phaser beam is slowed down within her hyperaccelerated time frame and she simply steps out of the way. Compton, also accelerated, has been helping the aliens run the ship. When he turns on them after Rael hurts Kirk, he gets struck, bleeds, and ages to death almost instantly. Kirk eventually seizes a Scalosian weapon, stuns Rael, and destroys the cryogenic device. Spock, who has also been accelerated, works out that the cause is polluted Scalosian water and brings back an antidote, which Kirk takes while Spock repairs the ship.
The critical reception in the article is mostly negative, and the criticism centers on the science. Dayton Ward says the premise is fine at first but falls apart on closer look, particularly the idea that a race this limited in imagination would need to mate with other species to survive. He does grant that it gives one of the series' more original redshirt deaths. David Alan Mack calls the idea decent but the execution weak, asking why the Scalosians would use suspended animation if time moves so slowly for them that knockout drugs would do. Zack Handlen gives it a B-minus, pointing to transporter problems and arguing the episode would have been stronger spending more time on the mystery. Melissa N. Hayes-Gehrke of the University of Maryland is the harshest, arguing that a stationary Scalosian should become briefly visible, that phaser beams can't be outrun, and that the ship's doors couldn't logically respond to beings the sensors can't detect. The article's Wikipedia-style sourcing makes clear that these critics agree on the hook and disagree sharply on whether the follow-through holds up.