How to find meaning in large tech companies
Sean Goedecke argues that people who hate big tech jobs often dislike the organizational mess itself, which makes it hard to engage with. He says the real meaning comes from the scale of impact: small improvements to widely used enterprise software reach millions of people.
- Many engineers' unhappiness comes less from dysfunction blocking their work and more from a compulsive disgust with messiness, which makes even thinking about the dysfunction feel tainting.
- Pretending to care about corporate rituals like OKRs and hype can be alienating and can slowly erode your sense that anything matters.
- Improving enterprise software that millions use is valuable, since every bug fix or feature saves users cumulative months or years of time, and slowing software decay is worthwhile.
Sean Goedecke argues that the usual explanation for why people hate large tech companies, that dysfunction blocks them from building things, is incomplete. Plenty of engineers don't just tolerate messiness; they find even thinking about the dysfunction repellent. He ties this to a compulsion toward neatness that many engineers share, and borrows Neal Stephenson's "The Book" from *Anathem*, a deliberately meaningless text whose punishment lies in pouring effort into an intellectual poison. Working in a bureaucracy also demands that you act invested in things like OKRs, deadlines, internal training, and manufactured hype. Getting good at that performance is lucrative but corrosive, and over time it can make importance itself feel like an illusion.
Goedecke, who holds a master's in philosophy with a specialty in moral epistemology, uses a personal example to illustrate the problem. People who come to him with existential dread expecting a philosophical cure should instead go do something that matters: spend time with their kids, walk in a park, read a good book, or see a doctor about medication. He suspects only a sliver of people, the truly philosophy-brained, have angst that comes from taking arguments seriously. Everyone else is simply depressed, and the cure is contact with real things, not more thinking about work. He also notes, with a wry caveat, that deriving your main sense of meaning from a job is a distinctly American habit.
Despite all this, he argues large companies offer real meaning, and the core of it is scale. A small video conferencing app used by a few people makes meaning rest entirely on craft. But a modest improvement to Microsoft Teams reaches millions of users, and every bug fixed or feature added saves cumulative months or years of collective time. He acknowledges that enterprise software tends to degrade and that the work often involves awkward workarounds and political games. Still, he sees the combination of hard engineering and hard organizational navigation as a rich source of meaning for anyone who tolerates mess, keeps a full personal life, and can treat office politics with detachment. He also gently pokes at outsiders who mock big-company engineers, noting the job is well paid and fairly relaxed.