EFF v. CMS

Open original

The Electronic Frontier Foundation filed a FOIA lawsuit to get records on WISeR, a Medicare program launched in January 2026 that uses AI to review prior authorization requests. The released documents include vendor contracts, accuracy and bias testing requirements, and status reports on how the program is running.

  • WISeR uses AI to assess prior authorization requests from Medicare beneficiaries, and experts and lawmakers have warned it could cause serious patient harm, including wrongful denials of care.
  • Little is public about how the algorithms work or what data they were trained on, and it is unclear whether safeguards exist against algorithmic bias or privacy violations.
  • The released records include participation agreements with six tech companies, reviewer criteria, a data reporting guide on vendor audits, and an actuary estimate of the program's impact.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation sued CMS under the Freedom of Information Act to get records on WISeR, a multi-state program launched in January 2026 that uses AI to review prior authorization requests from Medicare beneficiaries. The acronym stands for Wasteful and Inappropriate Service Reduction. The core worry is simple: an algorithm is being used to help decide whether patients get care, and almost nothing public is known about how it works, what data trained it, or whether it has safeguards against bias, privacy violations, or wrongful denials. Healthcare experts, providers, and lawmakers have raised alarms that the program could seriously harm patients if those safeguards are missing. The FOIA release is where the substance starts to come into focus. CMS handed over participation agreements with the six tech companies selected to do the assessments, covering their obligations, payment structures, oversight processes, and grounds for remedial action. It also released WISeR's Innovation Center Investment Plan from June 2025, which lays out the evidence base, strategy, expansion path, and legal framework. The reviewer guidebook shows how companies were scored and chosen, and a data reporting guide describes the audit processes and quality metrics vendors must meet. There are also status emails from Medicare Administrative Contractors describing technical glitches and figures on request volume and how quickly decisions were made, plus an Office of the Actuary estimate of the program's potential impact. Some of the more revealing material concerns oversight in practice. CMS sent requests for information and corrective action plans to four of the six vendors, and the vendors' responses are included, which gives a rare look at where things went wrong or needed fixing. Also in the release are applications from 66 companies, contracts for evaluating and monitoring the program, and surveys of medical providers about one of the vendors. What's still missing is the thing EFF's request specifically targeted: records showing tests for accuracy, bias, or hallucinations in the vendors' technology, and any audit or evaluation results. The article points out that these are the records that would actually answer whether WISeR is safe, and the release as described doesn't clearly show them, so the lawsuit's value depends on what else CMS is compelled to produce.

Ask about this article