Of Miracles and Moats
Packy McCormick's Not Boring essay argues that a useful technology doesn't guarantee good business returns: the pattern of a miracle tech attracting capital, overbuilding, and crashing prices has repeated from railways to airlines. He applies that cycle to AI and Anthropic, and says the three usual arguments against an AI bubble are the same steps that tend to precede one.
- The three standard arguments against an AI bubble (it's useful, it's growing fast, labs can be profitable) match the early steps of the boom-and-bust cycle that has repeated with past technologies.
- Airlines are the cautionary case: flight was a miracle technology, yet Buffett called aviation a suicidally competitive industry and Berkshire sold its airline stakes at a loss in 2020.
- Consumers tend to win from overbuilt technology even when investors lose, and durable competitive advantages (moats) are what decide which companies survive.
The core argument of this Not Boring essay is that a miracle technology does not guarantee a miraculous business. Packy McCormick uses airlines and internet service as the cautionary examples: the more useful a technology is, and the more money you can pour into scaling it, the more competitors pile in, build too much supply, and crash prices. He's writing against the backdrop of Anthropic's looming IPO, which he expects could open at a valuation far above where it closes its first week, and he floats scenarios ranging from Anthropic becoming a near-quadrillion-dollar company to a slowdown in revenue growth forcing it to sell itself to a buyer like Amazon or Apple. He refuses to call a bubble outright, which he thinks is a lazy, pessimistic stance, but he also refuses to predict which outcome wins.
His main analytical move is to take the three standard arguments against AI being a bubble (it's useful, the companies have real revenue and fast growth, and the labs can be profitable) and show they describe the early stage of the classic bubble cycle, not evidence against one. He lays out a ten-step pattern: a miracle technology arrives, early suppliers profit from scarcity, demand looks endless, capital and competitors flood in, everyone builds at once at scarcity prices, supply catches up, prices collapse, capital flees, a well-funded survivor becomes the low-cost provider, and eventually demand outgrows everyone's forecasts. He ties this to Carlota Perez's technological surge cycle and Edward Chancellor's capital cycle, and to Byrne Hobart and Tobias Huber's book defending bubbles.
To make it concrete, he points to aviation. The New York Times predicted flight was a million to ten million years away, two months before the Wright Brothers flew. Buffett's line that Orville did more damage to capitalists than Karl Marx sums up the outcome: airlines have been a graveyard for investors because durable competitive advantage has been hard to find. Packy's underlying point, which he says is unpopular right now, is that a business needs both a product customers want and a moat that protects it, and a great technology alone does not supply the second.