The Death of the Angel Investor

Open original

Zach Holman argues that the traditional angel investor role is shrinking, because superangels became fund managers, startups now reach revenue in hours, and huge valuations push out small checks. He still invests, points to tax advantages like QSBS and Roth-based startup investing, and launches "Dead Angels," a monthly San Francisco meetup for angels.

  • Many former superangels now raise small funds, since 2/20 economics beat investing their own money, and many 2021 and 2022 vintage funds took heavy losses.
  • Pre-seed funds and $30M to $100M+ seed rounds have squeezed out individual angels, and a 6x return on a $100M round is unappealing to wealthy investors.
  • Despite this, startups still want angel advisors and networks, and Holman thinks AI makes those relationships more valuable as technology becomes less of a differentiator.

Zach Holman, a longtime angel and former GitHub employee, argues that angel investing is losing its footing even as demand for angels stays high. He says founders at every stage, from pre-seed to Series B, keep asking him for angel introductions, yet he personally knows fewer angels than he used to. Part of the reason is economic. Old-school superangels have increasingly turned into small fund managers, collecting 2-and-20 on other people's money instead of writing personal checks. The number of solo GP and small funds has exploded, with many raised in the post-Covid frenzy of 2021 and 2022, and Holman expects some of those managers to get hit hard and reconsider whether venture suits them. The role of the angel has also shrunk. Historically, angels nursed a company from idea to first revenue, then handed off to VCs for growth capital. That gap has collapsed. Companies can go from idea to revenue in hours, and a wave of funds now targets pre-seed or earlier, so founders can raise one pre-seed fund rather than chase a dozen small checks from value-add individuals. Valuations push angels out too. Holman notes that AI-heavy decks can pull $30 million to $100 million-plus before the product is defined. A 6x return on a $100 million entry to a $600 million exit, after dilution, doesn't excite a very high net worth investor, and writing a check into a round that funds fifty engineers from day one takes away the fun of advising a scrappy team. Holman still invests and argues the case for it on three grounds. Returns aren't the whole point, and he likes helping people build companies, pointing to Alex Danco's 2019 essay on the social impact of angel work. He also says angel investing can pay financially if you're willing to move later, since he has made lucrative bets in Series B rounds despite preferring pre-seed and seed for fun. And he lists the tax advantages: QSBS, Section 1045 rollovers, Opportunity Zones, and tax-free startup investing through a Roth IRA. He thinks many of his millennial peers have aged out, moved away from the Valley, or simply don't need the risk anymore, while a new crop of millionaires from recent large IPOs should replenish the ranks. To encourage that, he's launching Dead Angels, a monthly drinks meetup in San Francisco, with the first session next week and sign-up at deadangels.com.

Ask about this article