Payments are the new ads
The author argues that paying through AI shopping agents is broken today, mostly because virtual cards and raw card numbers fail at checkout and banks haven't settled who is liable for mistakes. He sees prefunded stablecoin balances as a faster route around the banks, with network tokens likely catching up later.
- Agents usually pay with a one-time virtual card or raw card details, and both break often. Scott Wessman's Best Buy order failed when the store asked for a security code he had no way to retrieve.
- Six in ten UK adults told YouGov they'd stop using an AI shopping agent after one mistake, so reliability matters more than convenience.
- Prefunded agent balances, like Stripe Link's, skip the bank entirely. The author estimates they earn roughly four times what a one-time card leaves per purchase, which is why platforms are pushing them.
- Network tokens worked for Apple Pay because they came with clear liability rules and authentication. Agents don't have an equivalent yet, and banks like JPMorgan say they have no answer on who pays for mistakes.
Agentic shopping breaks in a predictable way. When an AI agent buys something, it usually either types in your real card number or charges a one-time virtual card issued by a platform like Stripe. The virtual card approach is what sank Scott Wessman's Best Buy order: Link charged his Amex, then paid through a Visa of its own, and when one item failed the store demanded a security code he couldn't find. The article cites YouGov data showing six in ten UK adults would stop using an AI shopping agent after one mistake. Still, the author points to Stripe Link users spending about $1,300 a month through Instinct as evidence that people will tolerate friction if the payoff is real.
Four payment paths exist today, and the two most common are the ones that break most. Raw card entry looks like fraud to merchants. One-time virtual cards hide what was bought from the customer's bank, and the author argues they're a bridge rather than a destination. Mastercard has signaled it doesn't see them as long-term, and they also wreck rewards and purchase protection. The two candidates for the future are network tokens, the model that made Apple Pay work with device tokens and fingerprint authentication, and prefunded stablecoin balances. Network tokens are stalled because nobody has settled who is liable when an agent makes a mistake. JPMorgan's Prashant Sharma said plainly, "I don't think that we have an answer at this particular point." Chase cards can't even be added to many agent platforms yet, and Visa has waived its passkey requirement for major agent platforms.
Balances offer a shortcut. Instinct's new Balance product lets a user load, say, $700 and set per-purchase limits, so the bank sees one authenticated top-up rather than every agent transaction. The author argues this simplifies the permission question to "is there enough money?" and makes the economics attractive to platforms, since Durbin caps the cost of a $100 debit top-up at roughly 27 cents for Stripe. The catch is that a balance proves funds, not intent, which is exactly why banks are wary of taking on the liability. The author expects both systems to coexist, with balances covering the gap until banks resolve the liability question.