Which would you work on first? Game mechanics or Art? : r/gamedev
A 2019 r/gamedev discussion where experienced developers argue that game mechanics should be prototyped before art, using placeholder graphics to test whether the core idea is fun. Commenters back this up with examples like Splatoon's gray-box prototype and Zelda: Breath of the Wild's 2D chemistry prototype.
- Build a basic prototype with gray boxes or placeholders to test whether the mechanics are fun before investing in art.
- Art done too early can clash with the mechanics, forcing wasted work and cut assets, as one commenter learned on an early project.
- Art should lead only when it is a key selling point; otherwise it should serve gameplay and narrative.
Reddit's r/gamedev thread asks whether a developer should build mechanics or art first, and the commenters land almost unanimously on mechanics. The core argument is that a game lives or dies on whether its core loop is fun, and you can only test that with cheap placeholder assets. One commenter, cpx9, says he made the classic beginner mistake of working on mechanics and graphics at the same time on an early project, ended up with "bad mechanics with okay graphics," and then had to cut art he'd finished because the mechanics that won out needed different assets. Aionigames makes the same point more bluntly: doing art first means you may spend weeks polishing something that doesn't fit the design you land on.
The thread backs this up with concrete examples. The top commenter, killeriukas, recommends modularizing the game and prototyping each mechanic in isolation, then swapping in better art once it works. His example is a smooth blending animation technique that simply can't coexist with a sprite sheet pipeline, so the art choice constrains what the mechanic can do. Another commenter points to the early gray-box build of Splatoon, which had nothing but gray boxes and still had its core ink-and-movement mechanics in place. A third mentions Nintendo building the chemistry system for Breath of the Wild as a 2D prototype before moving it into 3D. Taken together, these show mechanics being proven out with the crudest possible visuals before anyone invests in finished assets.
The main exception the thread allows is when art is itself the selling point. killeriukas says art should only lead if it's a key selling point, otherwise it exists to serve gameplay and narrative. A commenter cites Gris as a game with gorgeous art but relatively shallow mechanics that still earned strong reviews, which suggests the rule bends for games where the visual identity is the hook. The consensus advice, then, is to start with gray boxes, test whether the thing is fun, and let the art come in once the design has settled.