Game Mechanics & Systems Thinking

Open original

Joe Baxterweb argues that game designers often blur mechanics, rules, and systems together, and offers his own cleaner definitions. Mechanics are the player's verbs, rules are the underlying logic that builds them, and systems supply the objects those verbs act on.

  • Rules are the if-then logic of a game, and mechanics are made of rules. Small changes to a rule can make a mechanic feel completely different, such as coin collection in a platformer versus a VR game.
  • Core mechanics like jumping or dialogue clicking define a game's character, so their feel should be locked in early rather than treated as superficial.
  • Prototyping advice from Sid Meier: when testing a variable, double or halve it, since big swings reveal the effect of a rule change more clearly than tiny tweaks.

Game mechanics, in this video's framing, are the verbs of a game: the things the player can do to act on the game world, like jumping, collecting, avoiding, or escaping. They're distinct from rules, which are the underlying if-then logic that gets written as code, and from systems, which are larger bundles of rules such as a progression or traversal system. Mechanics are built out of rules, but they're specifically the interactive part, the stuff that produces gameplay. The speaker, Joe Baxterweb, also points out that the game itself can act through mechanics, not just the player. A difficulty system or enemy AI pushing back against the player is using the same kind of verbs, so mechanics aren't strictly the player's tools. The most useful point is that the same verb can feel completely different depending on its rules. Collecting a coin by walking into it, pressing a button to pick up a bag, or using a VR interface are all "collect," but each produces a different feel, and which one fits depends on the game's creative direction. Floating coins would feel wrong in a hard-boiled detective game, for example. The speaker's advice is to lock in the feel of core, repeated interactions early, because if your game is about jumping, the quality of jumping is the game's character. Even interface-heavy games, where the main interaction is clicking through menus or dialogue, have a mechanic whose feel matters. For prototyping, the advice is to change things aggressively. Attributed to Sid Meier, the rule is to double or halve a variable when testing it. Big swings make the effect of a rule change visible, while small tweaks tend to assume the current value is already close to right, which often isn't true. Treat early tuning as a way to find the direction a mechanic wants to go, not as fine polish. The video also gets somewhat philosophical and is long, so the speaker suggests watching in multiple sittings or at higher speed.

Ask about this article