A rising tide raises all rents

Open original

The author imagines AI making software and labor cheap, then asks who captures the gains. His answer: builders and incumbents get some, landlords and rent-seekers get most, and everyone else gets little unless society adopts something like a land-value tax for other scarce resources.

  • Four scenarios are walked through: status quo, a messy transition where new jobs offset displacement, reinstatement failure leading to plutocracy, and distributed ownership, with the first three analyzed as paths toward either instability or a rentier economy.
  • Citing Henry George, Enrico Moretti, and Richard Hornbeck, the author argues that when housing supply is tight, landlords capture nearly all productivity gains, so a guaranteed income like UBI at $50k would mostly flow into rent (around $25k).
  • He rejects revolution as a reliable route to a better outcome, arguing it more likely produces destruction or a new autocracy, and proposes that a scarce-resource equivalent of a land-value tax is needed to keep gains broadly shared.

The author's core claim is that if AI makes software and labor cheap, the gains won't be spread evenly. Scarcity moves to other things, and the people who control those scarce things (land, chokepoints, compute supply) capture the surplus. He argues that most of the productivity boom would flow to builders, incumbents, and especially landlords and rent-seekers, with little reaching everyone else. His proposed fix is a Land Value Tax analogue applied to other scarce resources, which he sketches toward the end of the post. He runs through five scenarios. The "status quo" world, where AI turns out to be roughly as impactful as the mobile phone, he considers unlikely. In a "messy transition" world, AI works and displaces many programmers and translators, but new roles like UI designer, sales engineer, and HCI researcher absorb the labor over a decade, citing a 2019 NBER paper on the "reinstatement effect." The darker case is "reinstatement failure": jobs shift faster than people can retrain, labor loses bargaining power against capital, wealth concentrates in a small plutocracy, and a post-modern colonialism plays out through control of GPU foundries and supply chains. He thinks that world is unstable, since mass unemployment eventually starves the demand the plutocrats depend on, leaving either a collapse or walled enclaves of the rich surrounded by the unemployed. For the political reactions, he rejects revolution as a reliable path, arguing that angry, long-unemployed people would more likely produce indiscriminate destruction, like the Butlerian Jihad or the book-burning of *A Canticle for Leibowitz*, than a utopian commons. He favors Universal Basic Income but doubts it ends poverty on its own, leaning on Eliezer Yudkowsky's argument that a life lacking one essential resource can still feel like poverty, which he admits he doesn't fully understand. His own gap in the argument is what he calls rent-seeking, which he says is where he's headed next and where the land-tax idea comes in.

Ask about this article