Straight Men Are Freaking Out About Their Butts
This New York Magazine piece looks at the rise of "glutemaxxing," a trend where straight men chase bigger, firmer glutes through heavy training, protein and creatine, partly driven by how often their butts are now shown on TV and in sports. The writer argues the pursuit has turned a simple appreciation of the ass into an over-optimized wellness project that has lost its erotic charge.
- Dylan, a self-described average guy, documented a three-month glute program (three sets of 12 reps, six days a week, about 200g protein daily, 10-15g creatine) and grew his following alongside his butt.
- The ideal has shifted from the flat 1980s butt to a high, muscular "football booty" modeled on athletes, while high fashion lags behind by designing pants for slimmer bodies.
- Men like Tom, who lost muscle during COVID and then on GLP-1 medication, describe feeling insecure about a "flat as a pancake" butt, showing how the trend affects straight men's self-image.
- The writer's central complaint is that obsessive optimization ("glutemaxxing") strips out the desire that made the ass appealing in the first place.
Dylan, a.k.a. Glute Max Guy, is the anchor of the piece. A fairly ordinary guy who'd lifted for a decade but ignored his lower body, he committed three months to "glutemaxxing": three sets of 12 reps, six days a week, a gram of protein per pound of bodyweight (roughly 200 grams), and 10 to 15 grams of creatine daily. He posts every session, and the reaction has been enthusiastic enough that he started a paid community, Glute Max Club, and says both his backside and his follower count have grown. The writer's point is that this kind of public, daily documentation is part of why the trend is spreading among straight men.
The bigger argument is about what counts as the ideal butt right now. The author traces a shift from the flat ’80s seat, through the ’90s tuck and the 2010s Brazilian butt lift, to today's firm, high, athletic "football booty" of the sort seen on hockey players and tennis stars. Shows like *Paradise*, *Reacher*, and *Heated Rivalry* have made male backsides a visible part of mainstream TV, and the piece argues that *Heated Rivalry* in particular helped renew appetite for them. Menswear is lagging, though. The author points out that Gucci, Prada, and the upstart Emily Dawn Long sent out low-slung or tight pants on models whose cheeks barely filled them, so the clothes and the desire don't quite match. Stylist Ian Bradley notes that fit options for men with thick thighs and big backsides have improved over the past six years.
The author's own take is mostly skeptical. He sees a real change in that straight men now feel they have something to offer in the attention economy that women and gay men have long valued. But he thinks glutemaxxing has overcomplicated a basic desire into a wellness project full of deadlifts, split squats, macro tracking, and a few awkward "activation" moves. Older men like Tom, 45, who lost his glutes after COVID and on a GLP-1 drug, illustrate the anxiety on the other side: the same culture that now prizes a good ass makes its absence feel like a personal failing.