Samsung Record Chip Profit Meets Shareholder Disappointment
Samsung posted a record quarterly chip profit driven by AI demand, but its shares fell up to 6.2% because it deferred its shareholder-return plan to January and gave a more cautious memory-shortage outlook than rival SK Hynix. Investors wanted more firm commitments than they got.
- Samsung's chip operating profit hit 106.5 trillion won in the July-September quarter, up from roughly 7 trillion a year earlier, though a little short of the 107.3 trillion analysts expected.
- Samsung delayed its next shareholder-return policy until January, which disappointed investors who had hoped for a fresh buyback or dividend now.
- Samsung expects the memory shortage to last through 2028, while SK Hynix sees it running to 2030, and that gap in outlook drove the selloff.
Samsung posted operating profit of 107.4 trillion won (about $80 billion) for July through September, up from 12.2 trillion won a year earlier, with chip profit alone at 106.5 trillion won. That chip figure was slightly below the 107.3 trillion won analysts expected, but the headline is still a roughly fifteen-fold jump in chip earnings, driven by AI demand for memory. The stock fell as much as 6.2% in morning trade after opening higher. The reason was less about the numbers than the signals around them. Rival SK Hynix had the day before said its DRAM and HBM chips were sold out through 2029 and that the shortage would last to 2030, and it laid out roughly $75 billion in shareholder returns. Samsung was more conservative: HBM supply is sold out for next year, but it expects the market to stay tight only through 2028. Analysts at BNK, Morningstar and CLSA all framed the drop as a comparison problem with SK Hynix's bolder outlook, plus disappointment that Samsung left its shareholder-return plan open.
On capital returns, Samsung had already guided to between 90 trillion and 110 trillion won for this year, including 30 trillion won in third-quarter dividends. Investors had hoped for an added buyback or dividend, but the company said it will set its next return policy in January. CLSA's Sanjeev Rana called that a likely near-term disappointment. The company also said it is spending 76.8 trillion won on capital expenditure next year, a 62% increase on this year, though it argues new fabs take time to build, which is part of why its tightness forecast is longer-dated than SK Hynix's. Broader worries also hang over the sector: concerns about how AI infrastructure gets financed, rising Chinese competition, and Alphabet's sharp rise in cash burn from AI spending, reported the same day.
The weaker spots are elsewhere in the business. Memory price increases are slowing as chipmakers sign more long-term contracts, and higher memory costs squeezed Samsung's mobile division into an 800 billion won loss. Its foundry unit is still losing money, though revenue improved on HBM logic dies and orders for advanced 2-nanometer chips from hyperscalers. Samsung says it has long-term supply deals with 10 major customers, is negotiating with 10 more, and wants such contracts to cover 60% to 70% of production capacity by 2030. Its Taylor, Texas plant starts mass production next year, making chips for Tesla. The company is also weighing a new fab for 2-nanometer chips. The core takeaway is that Samsung's profits are strong and its AI memory position is real, but the market is pricing it against a rival that sounded more confident about the cycle's length.