‘Cyberselfish’ author takes aim at techno-libertarianism as her book returns from the dead | TechCrunch

Open original

A Tin House reissue of Paulina Borsook's 2000 book Cyberselfish, which argued that Silicon Valley's anti-government, techno-libertarian worldview was both hypocritical and deeply rooted. In this interview, Borsook explains how she came to the topic and says the trends she flagged have only spread since the dot-com crash.

  • Borsook says tech leaders are strongly anti-regulation even though no sector has benefited more from government funding and infrastructure, pointing to R&D and the clean water at Lake Tahoe as examples.
  • She separates "Ravers" (culturally liberal, Burning Man types) from "Gilders" (social conservatives named after George Gilder), and says that split still holds today.
  • She argues the trend is continuous rather than new, dating the shift to the Netscape IPO, when finance people took over the culture, and sees the same pattern in current tech alignment with the Trump administration.

Paulina Borsook's 2000 book "Cyberselfish" is back in print from Tin House, with a new introduction by Gil Durán, the author of "The Nerd Reich." The book went out of print long ago, but used copies started climbing in price last year, social media posts praised it out of nowhere, and European academics started asking about it. That revival led to renewed press, including a New York Times piece saying readers wanted to understand why the tech industry "lost its way." Borsook says the book is best read as a travelogue of her attempt to make sense of the techno-libertarian streak in Silicon Valley, not a polemic. She has published no second book, and says that after the first one nobody wanted to hear from her about tech. Her origin story is a personal one. She grew up in Pasadena around Caltech and JPL, where engineers had a clear sense of what government could do for them and didn't brag about their own greatness. When she moved into Bay Area tech circles in the early-to-mid 1980s, she found a different temperament, and by the early 1990s she kept hearing offhand remarks about government and self-interest that she couldn't parse. Her agent, after her MFA at Columbia, asked whether she had a nonfiction book in her, and she set out to understand the subculture. Her core argument is that the anti-regulation outlook persisted after the dot-com crash, even though, as she puts it, no sector had benefited more and suffered less from government than tech. She describes it as a "basket of beliefs" that spread like contamination in an aquifer. She also says most of the 1990s tech writing was celebratory, which is why this critical angle got so little attention. Borsook's sharpest distinction is between two camps she named after figures of the era: "Gilders," social conservatives after George Gilder, and "Ravers," culturally liberal types who took their cue from John Perry Barlow and the Burning Man scene. She thinks that split has held up, with religious conservatives in leadership roles alongside people experimenting with drugs, sexuality, effective altruism, and AI. She is careful to say she is describing culture, not electoral politics, noting that the Peninsula still votes Democratic and that rank-and-file workers may be less ideological than their bosses. Her more pointed observation is about the employees who privately disagree with leaders like Elon Musk but stay because jobs are less secure now. That precarity, she argues, makes people more willing to tolerate politics they don't share.

Ask about this article