The 10 Products That Defined the Strategist

Open original

New York Magazine's shopping guide marks its tenth year by naming the ten products that shaped it, each chosen for what it says about both the site and the history of online shopping. The early pieces covered things like Japanese nail clippers and seamless underwear, and the site has since grown to cover the flood of deals, affiliate links, and social commerce.

  • The Strategist started in 2016 as a guide to buying things online, back when people couldn't see or touch products before purchase and needed trusted reviewers to decide what was worth it.
  • Many early finds were items previously only available abroad, like Green Bell nail clippers from Japan, which turned out to be sold on Amazon, showing how quickly global products became reachable online.
  • The site's model moved from long, personal product essays toward constant deal coverage, and the piece argues this shift tracked broader changes in shopping, from Black Friday going online to affiliate links being everywhere.

The Strategist, New York Magazine's shopping guide, turns ten, and the anniversary piece looks back at how online shopping changed over that stretch. In 2016, buying a mattress online felt like a gamble and nobody could see a T-shirt before paying for it, so the Strategist positioned itself as a trusted filter for the flood of new direct-to-consumer brands. The early site leaned on long, personal essays from writers like Molly Young and Stephanie Danler rather than spec sheets, and that voice became the template. Discount hunting has also shifted in a decade. Black Friday went fully virtual, Prime Day became a twice-yearly event, and price trackers like CamelCamelCamel moved from niche tool to everyday habit. The Strategist now runs daily deal coverage and a dedicated newsletter to keep pace. The bulk of the piece is a ranked list of ten "canon" products, each picked for what it says about the site and about shopping history. The first two entries show the range. Jason Chen, then a Strategist deputy editor, found Green Bell nail clippers in Narita airport for 1,700 yen and was surprised to discover them already sold on Amazon, which made him realize Japan-only goods were suddenly one click away. That same era brought Midori pens, Hobonichi Techo planners, Nuxe dry oil and other imports that used to require a friend's carry-on. Lauren Levy's entry is about YogaToes, the ladder-shaped toe separators she started using to head off bunions and hammertoes after watching her grandmother lose two toes to surgery. She notes that her mother, who once spent heavily on shoes, switched to the toe separators for comfort, and that the site's appetite for odd, underrated gadgets, from TubShroom to AirPod condoms, is part of its identity. The remaining entries continue the pattern of pairing a specific object with a specific moment in online retail, though the excerpt cuts off before covering them. The through-line is that the Strategist's value lies less in ranking products by specification and more in tracking how people found, bought and lived with small useful things, and how that discovery process itself moved from in-person hunting to algorithmic feeds full of TikTok Shop, Temu and affiliate links.

Ask about this article