We're two cheaters in a toxic situationship; she hurt me; but we're destined to be together
A caller describes a two-year on-off affair with an ex who is now dating someone else, and asks whether he is a bad person for trying to make it work. The hosts push back hard, arguing the emotional framing is melodramatic and that he is effectively being the side partner.
- The caller admits he cheated first, then she cheated back, and both now frame their guilt as mutual and their reunion as fate.
- The hosts argue that staying in an ongoing side arrangement while she dates someone else makes reconciliation less likely, and that he is being cheated on emotionally too.
- The working advice is to end both current relationships, have a clear "we both messed up, now onward" conversation, and only then try again.
A caller on what sounds like a late-night radio show, with the hosts riffing on him, describes a messy two-year situationship. He cheated on a girlfriend with the woman he now wants back. She found out, kept seeing him for a while, then ended things, got into a relationship with another man, and reached back out to him while still with that guy. He admits she didn't tell him she was still seeing her boyfriend when she started pursuing him again. He says they both feel guilt, that she loves him but isn't sure she can forgive him, and he asks whether it's wrong to keep trying to make it work when he was the one who did wrong first.
The hosts mostly roll their eyes at the framing. They think he's trying to rewrite the story so he looks less culpable, and they push back on his "who's worse" comparison. One host points out the timeline is confusing: he broke up with his ex to pursue this woman, she then got a boyfriend, and now she's back in contact while still with that boyfriend. The core argument is that morality over who cheated first doesn't matter much. What matters is whether the relationship makes both people feel safe, non-judged, and honest. The hosts also note that there's a real emotional cost to being the side partner, even if no legal line is crossed, and that he's effectively being cheated on too by a woman who has a boyfriend.
Their advice is blunt: he can't keep seeing her while she's with someone else and expect it to become something real. The only workable path they see is a clean reset, where both get out of their current situations, both own the mistakes they made, and then decide whether they want to try again on equal footing. Nothing in the segment suggests this is a settled outcome, and the hosts make clear they think he's still leaning on a story that flatters him more than it should.