The Last Thing My Mother Wanted
Jennifer Senior's account (as the byline suggests, the author is the daughter) follows her 74-year-old mother, who has no terminal diagnosis, as she applies to Pegasos, a Swiss group that assists people who are simply "tired of life." It is as much a reckoning with a difficult, emotionally distant parent as it is a look at the end-of-life process.
- Her mother had no terminal or incurable illness; Pegasos accepts elderly applicants who say their quality of life is poor, a far looser standard than the U.S. or Canadian laws require.
- The mother's stated reasons were a dim view of the world, loss of joy in everyday life and relationships, and fear of the indignities of aging and of becoming a burden.
- The piece is interwoven with the author's memories of an unstable childhood shaped by her mother's affairs and abandoned projects, making the question of whether her mother will actually go through with it feel personal as well as medical.
The author's 74-year-old mother, a healthy woman with a cataract, foot pain, and a pacemaker but no terminal diagnosis, applied to Pegasos, a Swiss voluntary-assisted-death organization, in June 2022. In September, the family sat with the Pegasos anesthesiologist in a Basel hotel, where he explained the lethal dose of Nembutal, 15 grams, and reassured them she would not wake up or be cremated alive. The mother's stated reasons were that the world was getting worse, that she no longer found joy in everyday life or relationships, and that she dreaded the indignities of aging. Her long-term partner had died through California's death-with-dignity law in 2020, and after that she moved back to New York and seemed to lose interest in nearly everything. The only thing that seemed to bring her real pleasure in her final months was the prospect of dying.
The piece is less a story about the decision itself than about the family history that surrounds it. The mother had a long record of abandoned projects, unused degrees, and threats she never carried out, including crossing the author out of her will and then quietly reversing it. The author, who wanted some reckoning with her mother's parenting, describes childhood memories of an affair that became known in kindergarten, a second affair with a Columbia anthropology professor, and a household where secrets were not kept. The author's uncertainty about whether her mother would really go through with it gives the essay a constant undertow: she half-expected a last-minute reversal, and she was also searching for some acknowledgment of the harm her mother had caused.
The article also lays out the legal landscape. In the U.S., ten states allow physician-assisted death, but only for terminally ill residents with six months or less to live. Canada permits assistance for incurable conditions with intolerable suffering, and Switzerland has the loosest rules, allowing aid for people who are simply tired of life. Pegasos costs more than $10,000 and is one of the few organizations willing to help people without a terminal diagnosis. The author's account raises the question of how that "tired of life" category gets assessed, especially when no mental illness was documented and the mother had refused therapy her whole life, a fact that the author notes would normally prompt closer scrutiny.