Can Do vs. Can’t Do Cultures | Andreessen Horowitz

Open original

A venture capitalist argues that big companies stall on innovation because one skeptic can kill an idea, while leaders like Larry Page back ideas that look bad at first. He backs this with historical examples of dismissed technologies, from Babbage's computer to Bell's telephone and early internet criticism.

  • Big companies often kill new ideas because a hierarchy must agree, and a single skeptic can block a project, creating a "Can't Do Culture."
  • Truly innovative ideas usually look like bad ideas at first, which is why leaders who fund them despite objections, like Larry Page at Google, build a "Can Do Culture."
  • Historical dismissals, including the British Treasury abandoning Babbage's Analytical Engine in 1842, Western Union rejecting the telephone, and Clifford Stoll doubting the web in 1995, show that critics often focus on what technology can't do yet rather than what it might do.

Andreessen Horowitz's a16z published this essay arguing that the tech world is sliding from a culture of hope and experimentation into one of smug dismissal. The author, a venture capitalist, claims that Twitter and other feeds are full of gleeful takedowns of struggling startups and founders. His core distinction is between a "Can Do Culture" and a "Can't Do Culture." Big companies usually fail at innovation, he argues, because a new idea has to clear a chain of approvals, and a single skeptical manager can kill it, often to look smart or protect turf. Google and Amazon, by contrast, are run by people like Larry Page, who will fund an idea that looks bad and wave off objections. He also makes the point that truly innovative ideas usually look like bad ideas at the time, which is partly why they're innovative. To make the case, he leans on three historical examples. Charles Babbage designed the Analytical Engine in 1837, a machine that was in principle Turing-complete, but he never finished it. In 1842, the astronomer George Biddell Airy advised the British Treasury that it was useless, and the project was dropped. The telephone fared similarly: Western Union's internal committee reportedly turned down Alexander Graham Bell's offer to sell his patents for $100,000, calling the device a toy. And in 1995, astronomer Clifford Stoll wrote in Newsweek that the web would never amount to much, pointing to the lack of trustworthy online payments and the absence of salespeople. The author's diagnosis is that all of these critics judged technology by what it couldn't yet do, rather than by what it might do with time and effort. His closing argument is that the cynics hurt themselves most. People who fixate on what's wrong with an idea become too timid to try anything others find absurd, too envious to learn from innovators, and too dismissive to spot the next major talent. The piece is short on data and long on anecdote, and it treats criticism of startups as a single phenomenon without much attention to cases where the skepticism was warranted. Its real audience is founders and investors who want permission to back long shots, and read that way, it's a pitch for patience as much as an argument about culture.

Ask about this article