Doing old things better vs doing brand new things

Open original

New technologies first get used to do existing tasks faster or cheaper, but the bigger impact comes from products that enable things nobody could do before. Chris Dixon argues that most people evaluate new tech too narrowly by focusing on the first category.

  • Early uses of new technology usually copy old workflows: early films were filmed like stage plays, and early web products mirrored letter writing and mail-order shopping.
  • The truly transformative products, like social networking and crowdfunding, only appeared on the web in the 2000s, years after the technology existed.
  • Blockchain is a useful case study: cheaper payments are the obvious benefit, but user-owned internet services are the more significant opportunity.

New technologies, Chris Dixon argues, enable two kinds of activity. The first is doing things you could already do, only faster, cheaper, or better. The second is doing things that were impossible before. The first kind gets most of the early attention because it's easy to picture. Early films were filmed stage plays with a better distribution model, and the early electrical grid mostly replaced gas and candles for light. Early web products were digital versions of letter writing and mail-order catalogs. But Dixon's point is that the second category, the genuinely new, is what ends up reshaping the world. The clearest examples come from the internet and business software. Early films didn't develop their own visual grammar until filmmakers stopped copying theater, and it took decades before the electrical grid grew an "app store" of appliances. On the web, social networking, crowdfunding, crowdsourced knowledge bases, and cryptocurrency only took off in the 2000s. In business software, Salesforce's early appeal was mostly that it was easier to access and cheaper to run than on-premise software. Newer tools like Google Docs, Figma, and Slack went further, offering real-time collaboration and deep integrations that simply weren't feasible before. Dixon also warns about blockchains: cheaper, faster global payments matter, but they're the easy case. The more interesting possibility is internet services owned and run by their users rather than by a company. Dixon's advice for judging a new technology is to look past the obvious efficiency gains and ask what becomes possible that wasn't. The founders behind genuinely new categories tend to spend years immersed in the underlying technology before they have their key insight, and their early products often look like toys, odd, unserious, expensive, or even dangerous. They improve over time, and the world slowly comes around. By his reading, cryptocurrencies, machine learning, and virtual reality are still early, and mobile devices, cloud hosting, social networks, and the internet itself may be too. That means the most important products built on those foundations probably haven't been invented yet.

Ask about this article