Nathan Fielder Tells Us Everything
Wired's Katie Drummond describes the frantic, NDA-bound rollout of Nathan Fielder's secret documentary "You Can See Everything," co-directed with Lance Oppenheim and built around Elizabeth Holmes. The piece pairs her praise for the film with an interview in which Fielder explains why he kept the project hidden for three years.
- The film was screened in secret at the Telluride Film Festival in early September, and only a few dozen people saw it beforehand under NDA.
- Fielder says secrecy protected the subjects from paparazzi and kept press narratives from shaping the project before it was finished.
- Drummond calls the film one of the best she has seen and says it shifted from a psychological study of Holmes and her partner Billy Evans into something stranger than Fielder could have designed.
Katie Drummond, WIRED's editor-in-chief, got a surprise email from Nathan Fielder's publicist asking whether WIRED wanted him for a fall cover. The catch was a secret project, so tightly guarded that she had to sign an NDA before even hearing what it was. That project was "You Can See Everything," co-directed by Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, which premiered as a surprise addition to the Telluride Film Festival in early September. Only a few dozen people had seen it by then. The film follows Fielder's roughly 34-day psychological dance with Elizabeth Holmes and her partner Billy Evans before Holmes went to prison. Drummond calls it one of the best films she's ever seen, and says she couldn't stop thinking about it, and that a small group of WIRED staffers spent hours afterward arguing over its facial expressions, relationships, and individual lines.
Getting Fielder on the cover was its own ordeal. He flipped between yes and no for weeks, leaving Drummond and the features director without sleep, and Drummond admits she told people she hated him, then loved him, depending on the day. Their sit-down conversation in late September, lasting nearly an hour and a half, went well. Drummond describes Fielder as considerate and earnest, if verbally awkward, and notes that his bluntness makes him effective as a truth-seeker in the film. The interview ended at 2:17 pm, and Fielder left for a Zoom meeting scheduled for 2:15, a time that struck Drummond as odd for a Sunday. She wondered whether she'd been lied to, by Fielder or his publicist, but decided not to ask. She chose to trust them instead, and says Holmes may have come to a similar view.
The published interview itself centers on secrecy. Fielder explains that the project was hidden partly to protect the subjects, since paparazzi began gathering at the filming location, and partly because public attention could have shaped the story or complicated access to the people involved. He says they had no fixed plan going in, so keeping the project unknown seemed to offer a net benefit. When Drummond asks how many people he had to lie to, he says he didn't lie so much as decline to discuss it, telling people he was working on something they'd see later. The piece is worth reading if you want a sense of how Fielder operates, and it is a fairly candid look at how much of his work depends on controlling what the audience knows before they walk in.