There's little that's "inevitable" about AI | deadSimpleTech

Open original

The author argues that LLMs don't meet the criteria that make technologies truly "inevitable" — they can't match human quality at high levels, they only replace low-value work, and they don't deliver the overwhelming performance gains that force adoption. Just because a technology is powerful doesn't mean society has no real choice about using it.

  • A technology becomes inevitable only when it massively outperforms alternatives, performs socially valuable work, and leaves no way to neutralize its impact without radical behavioral change. Firearms met all three criteria in medieval Europe; the magnetic compass didn't, and remained optional.
  • LLMs can only replace the least valuable parts of knowledge work — mediocre code, superficial research, low-quality design — while human expertise remains essential for anything requiring real quality. The more important the work, the less useful LLMs become.
  • Real-world LLM efficiency gains are modest (20-50% improvement in low-stakes work like dashboards) and shrink dramatically as you approach actual business bottlenecks. If LLMs were truly overpowering, we'd already see tech companies producing vastly more output with them.

The author challenges the claim that LLMs are "inevitable" by first defining what technological inevitability actually means. A technology becomes inevitable when it performs tasks at least as well as alternatives, addresses socially valuable needs, massively outperforms competing solutions, and can't be neutralized through behavioral changes. Gunpowder weapons exemplify true inevitability—once they arrived in medieval Europe, militaries had no choice but to adopt them or face conquest. By contrast, the magnetic compass was merely useful; societies could still thrive without it by focusing on land power instead. The key insight is that inevitability isn't intrinsic to a technology itself but depends entirely on cultural and social structures. A wheel is useless in dense jungle without roads, just as cannons were less militarily transformative in China than Europe because of different fortification styles. Applying these criteria to LLMs, the author finds they're on shakier ground. LLMs can match mediocre human work—which comprises most actual labor—so they pass the first test. But the social value criterion falters. Much of the knowledge work LLMs target isn't actually scarce; there's no pressing shortage forcing adoption. Unlike siege warfare or maritime navigation, organizations can simply choose not to use LLMs without catastrophic consequences. The article cuts off mid-analysis, but the trajectory suggests LLMs fail the inevitability test because people retain genuine alternatives. The author's framework demolishes the "just accept it" fatalism surrounding AI adoption. Technologies aren't destiny—they're choices constrained by real circumstances. When someone claims LLMs are inevitable, they're really asserting a prediction about power dynamics, not describing an immutable law of nature. Whether that prediction holds depends on whether societies actually need LLMs to survive competitively, not on the technology's mere existence.

Ask about this article