Gavin Newsom’s Struggle for Everyman Cred
A scathing review of Gavin Newsom's autobiography finds it riddled with contradictions—he tries to establish himself as an everyman while obsessively documenting his deep connections to the Getty family and California's elite. The book undermines itself by revealing that his political instincts are primarily about personal ambition rather than conviction.
- Newsom's memoir references the Getty family 61 times across 270 pages while claiming they didn't shape his success, creating a self-defeating attempt to rebrand his image as a self-made politician.
- The book reveals his cynical approach to homelessness policy in San Francisco—he explicitly states that Proposition N was valuable because it "burnished my credentials for a run at higher office" rather than for any actual impact on vulnerable people.
- Newsom's current political positioning is incoherent: he markets himself as Trump's fierce opponent on social media while simultaneously platforming far-right figures like Steve Bannon and Ben Shapiro on his podcast and agreeing with their positions.
The reviewer compares Newsom's memoir to a corporate propaganda museum—technically well-written but fundamentally dishonest about its subject. Newsom claims the media has wronged him by portraying him as a Getty family tool, and he wrote this book to reclaim his "hard-earned story." The problem: he spends 270 pages proving exactly what he denies. The Gettys appear 61 times across the index. They funded 10 of his 11 businesses, took him on vacations with Mary Leakey and King Juan Carlos, and he was mistaken for their children so often he might as well have been one. Meanwhile, he tosses in token "relatable" details—his mother took in lodgers, he had a paper route—as if these offset a lifetime of elite connections to the Pelosis, Rick Barry, Jack Nicholson, and Pavarotti.
The memoir actually contains genuinely sympathetic material that could have worked. Newsom struggled with severe dyslexia, his father was emotionally distant, he battled alcohol issues, his mother died by assisted suicide, his first marriage failed partly due to his own infidelities, and his current wife suffered a miscarriage. But he handles these moments perfunctorily while dwelling on privilege. He mentions getting into Santa Clara University but omits that Jerry Brown wrote his recommendation letter. He describes founding a winery at 24 with Gordon Getty's money as if it were a bootstraps story.
The political content reveals something worse than tone-deafness. Newsom takes pride in Proposition N (2002), which cut cash assistance to homeless people in San Francisco. He explicitly states the real lesson he learned wasn't about helping vulnerable people—it was that the measure "burnished my credentials for a run at higher office" and showed him "it was better to be aligned with the people than with the pundits." He wrote that sentence knowing exactly what it meant. The memoir becomes a document where Newsom accidentally confesses that policy affecting thousands of desperate people was ultimately just a stepping stone in his climb.