Everyone can find a reason to dislike data center construction | TechCrunch
A new study of Pennsylvania residents reveals that opposition to AI data centers isn't driven by foreign interference or simple NIMBYism, but by a diverse coalition worried about power bills, property values, corporate secrecy, and broken trust with local officials. The research shows people are skeptical of industry's "inevitable progress" pitch based on their region's history of industrial exploitation.
- Over 60% of Americans support limiting data centers, with $68 billion in projects disrupted in Q2 2026 alone; Pennsylvania Governor Shapiro reversed his support within a year and imposed new restrictions.
- Opposition comes from an unlikely coalition: environmental groups, AI skeptics, unions (supporting for jobs), NIMBYs, and residents noticing developers using NDAs and corporate influence tactics at town halls.
- People's core concerns are material and relational—higher power bills, falling property values, and eroded trust with local officials who suddenly won't discuss data center deals.
AI companies want to build massive data centers to power their models, and they're planning to spend trillions doing it. The public, though, isn't on board. Over 60% of Americans oppose new data center construction, especially locally, and that number's climbing fast. In the second quarter of 2026 alone, $68 billion worth of data center projects got derailed by local opposition. The industry has tried blaming foreign interference for the backlash, but that story doesn't hold up. Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro's shift tells you everything—he was cheerleading a $90 billion infrastructure investment in July 2025, then a year later he signed an order adding new regulatory requirements and killed the fast-track approval process.
A new Data & Society report based on 18 months of fieldwork and interviews with 44 Pennsylvanians explains what's actually driving the opposition. It's not one thing. Pennsylvania residents have lived through coal mining, oil booms, steel manufacturing, and fracking—they've learned to recognize when they're being sold a bill of goods about "inevitable" industrial progress. The resistance crosses traditional political lines in surprising ways. You've got classic NIMBYs, people skeptical of AI itself, environmental groups worried about water and energy use, and folks concerned about power bills going up or property values dropping. What ties them together is material self-interest and a growing distrust of how these companies operate—the NDAs they ask officials to sign, the way they suddenly show up at town halls and local politicians go silent.
The real problem for the AI industry is that there's no single fix. You can't address a coalition this diverse with one message or one concession. The core issue is trust, which the industry has already damaged. People feel the contradiction between AI being pitched as inevitable progress while simultaneously knowing they're being extracted from—their data, their attention, their relationship to technology itself. That gap between the promise and the reality is what's fueling the pushback, and it's not going away.