The AI graveyard: a running list of projects and startups that didn't make it | TechCrunch
A TechCrunch rundown of AI products and startups that have shut down or flopped, from Relay to Humane AI Pin to Microsoft's Recall. The piece shows that even massive companies like OpenAI and Apple struggle to make AI bets stick, with 42% of corporate AI initiatives ultimately abandoned.
- 42% of AI initiatives launched by corporations get abandoned, with failures driven by insufficient funding, technical challenges, competition, or weak user demand
- Major tech companies including OpenAI, Apple, and Microsoft have had high-profile AI failures: OpenAI killed ChatGPT Atlas and Sora; Apple delayed Siri AI by years; Microsoft's Recall faced persistent privacy backlash even after redesign
- Smaller AI startups like Relay, Humane AI Pin, and Rabbit R1 couldn't compete when larger platforms built similar features directly into their existing products or user bases
The AI industry is littered with dead projects, and the pattern is clear: bigger companies absorb smaller competitors' features, and standalone AI tools struggle to justify their existence. Relay, a five-year-old automation platform, just shut down because OpenAI and Google built similar tools directly into their own products. According to S&P Global Market Intelligence, 42% of AI initiatives get abandoned by their corporate parents due to weak demand, technical problems, or inability to scale. Even massive players like OpenAI have stumbled repeatedly—the company killed ChatGPT Atlas (a web browser) in under a year, shut down Sora due to high costs and poor retention, and had to roll back a confusing redesign that tried to turn ChatGPT into a "super app." The lesson here isn't that AI is failing broadly, but that standalone products face brutal headwinds when entrenched platforms can simply copy the feature and ship it to millions of existing users overnight.
Hardware and specialized AI devices have been particularly brutal graveyards. Humane raised $230 million for its AI Pin wearable, only to face battery fire risks and poor performance before shutting down in February 2025—HP bought the assets for just $116 million. The Rabbit R1 launched with massive hype at CES 2024 and claimed 100,000 early sales, but reviews called it unfinished with unreliable performance and limited integrations. It's still limping along with updates. Smaller software plays died too: Huxe (podcast-style audio from written text) shut down as Spotify expanded similar features, Yupp (an AI model comparison playground) couldn't find product-market fit despite 800+ models, and Figgs AI (AI character roleplay) became too expensive to run for free despite hitting 1 million users.
Microsoft and Apple showed that even being a tech giant doesn't guarantee smooth launches. Microsoft's Recall feature—pitched as a searchable screenshot archive for Windows—triggered immediate privacy backlash when announced in 2024, and a security researcher recently demonstrated a tool to extract Recall's captured data, suggesting the redesigned version still has fundamental problems. Apple promised improved Siri as part of Apple Intelligence in 2024 but delayed it repeatedly due to bugs, eventually settling a $250 million lawsuit over misleading iPhone 16 marketing claims. Notion Mail launched in April 2025 as an AI email organizer but discovered users preferred separate AI agents for email handling, so it's shutting down September 22. These failures show that the AI graveyard isn't just full of scrappy startups—it's full of well-funded bets from companies with resources and distribution, killed by either competition from larger platforms, poor product-market fit, or fundamental technical and privacy problems.