The Cold Email

Open original

The author shares three pivotal stories—from getting off a university waitlist to landing a GitHub job and owning a soccer club—to show how unsolicited outreach opened doors. He admits most cold emails go nowhere but argues the handful that work make it worth trying, as long as you’re genuine and respectful. He also pledges to keep his inbox open to pay it forward.

  • CMU only admits 1–10% of waitlisted students, but an unsolicited extra essay from Holman got him in
  • A bold cold email to GitHub's cofounder led to an on-the-spot hire, since a $60k junior role was low risk for the startup
  • A cold Twitter DM turned into part-ownership of a soccer club, which later led to a stake in a Serie A team
  • He only remembers the cold outreach attempts that worked, not the ones that failed, so survivorship bias shouldn't discourage trying

Zach Holman’s first big win from cold outreach was getting off Carnegie Mellon’s waitlist. His dad encouraged him to overnight an extra essay detailing his work on Good-Tutorials, then the internet’s largest tutorial site, plus other materials about his senior year. A few days later he got in—CMU only admits about 1–10 percent of waitlisted students—so that extra push mattered. In 2010, Holman spotted a tweet from GitHub cofounder Chris Wanstrath looking for junior Ruby developers. He admitted he barely knew Java but shot off a bold email anyway. They met at Hotel Utah and hired him on the spot for a $60k junior role—low risk for a cash-strapped startup. Six years ago, a cold Twitter DM landed him part-ownership in a soccer club. That led to another stake in a Serie A team and steered his career toward sports tech investments and volunteer work. He can’t name the cold emails that failed—only the ones that changed his life. That selective memory, he argues, shouldn’t scare you off. Cold outreach is awkward but necessary. Do your homework, show genuine interest, and don’t treat it like a numbers game. Holman also underscores how recipients benefit. He vows to read any cold resume or pitch he gets, since others did the same for him. Opening doors for strangers expands networks and breaks blind spots. So when it feels right, reach out—and be ready to pass the favor on.

Ask about this article