@maxrumpf - Pick the Right Problem

Open original

@maxrumpf on X Max Rumpf argues that the biggest driver of outsized research success is choosing the right problem, not working harder on a weak one. He frames it as a reread-every-few-months essay about how to pick and stick with research questions.

  • The most important determinant of outsized success is picking the right problem.
  • The piece is a short reminder meant to be revisited every few months, not a one-time read.

The post itself is a short tweet-length note, and it leans on a title, "You and Your Research," that points to Richard Hamming's well-known 1986 talk of the same name, given at Bell Labs. The only substance in the post is its core claim: the most important determinant of outsized success is picking the right problem. Beyond that, the author is recommending a re-read every few months, so the value here is the original talk the post is pointing toward, not the post's own text. Hamming's argument, as the title suggests, is about how people in research can produce work that matters. He was blunt about the gap between the great and the merely good, and he pushed readers to ask themselves what the important problems in their field are and whether they are working on one. His famous habit was to pose that question to colleagues over lunch, and he used the fact that most people had no good answer as his point. He also argued that people who do significant work tend to keep a sense of direction, spend time thinking about the big open questions, and are willing to take a risk on something that might not pan out. For someone deciding whether to save this, the practical takeaway is this: the post is a pointer, and it's worth saving only as a reminder to go find the full talk and read it in its entirety. The one-line summary is a fair compression of Hamming's point, but the talk's examples and his reasoning about why people drift toward safe problems are where the real content is.

Ask about this article