Tommy Siegel (@TommySiegel)
Short summary
Tommy Siegel tweets that his favorite New Yorker submission of the year was rejected. He shares the overlooked piece to highlight the magazine’s selection process. It’s a brief nod to what didn’t make the cut.
- Tommy Siegel tweeted that a New Yorker cartoon rejection was "perhaps my favorite" of the year, without explaining why.
- The tweet itself was only 41 characters long, relying on the attached image/submission to make its point.
Full summary
Tommy Siegel zeroes in on a single submission the New Yorker turned down this year—and calls it his top reject so far. He doesn’t spell out why in the tweet, but by labeling it “perhaps my favorite,” he’s flagging something he finds exceptional. The phrasing hints at wit or originality that didn’t line up with the magazine’s final cut, yet stood out enough for Siegel to spotlight amid countless other declines.
By singling out this one piece, Siegel invites readers to hunt down the text themselves. He trusts that anyone familiar with the New Yorker’s taste—tight narration, sharp voice, inventive angle—will see why this particular draft earned his personal nod. The tweet itself runs just 41 characters; its power lies in sparking curiosity about a story deemed too good to ignore, despite its official rejection.