project deal
Anthropic ran Project Deal, where Claude AI agents negotiated buying and selling personal items on behalf of 69 employees in a Slack-based classifieds market. They compared outcomes between a top-tier model (Opus 4.5) and a smaller one (Haiku 4.5), finding that smarter agents secured higher prices and more deals—differences participants didn’t notice. In total, agents struck 186 deals worth just over $4,000.
- Anthropic had 69 employees delegate real negotiations to Claude agents, resulting in 186 deals worth about $4,000 in a week.
- Agents running Opus 4.5 closed roughly two more deals and got better prices than those running Haiku 4.5, despite identical budgets and rules.
- Haiku users didn't notice they were getting worse outcomes, rating their results as fair anyway—exposing a gap between perceived and actual performance.
- This hints at a near-future where the AI model you choose quietly determines who wins in everyday automated commerce.
Anthropic’s Project Deal had 69 employees hand off a $100 gift-card budget to custom Claude agents, then watched as those bots listed, bid on, haggled over, and closed deals for real items in a Slack-based marketplace. Over a week in December 2025, the agents struck 186 trades worth just over $4,000, moving everything from snowboards to ping-pong balls. Participants never saw a human intervene—once prompts were set, their AI reps handled every step, from spotting matches to drafting the final agreement.
To test model strength, Anthropic ran four parallel markets. Two runs used only Claude Opus 4.5, their top-tier model. The other two mixed in Claude Haiku 4.5 for half the agents. In the end, people with Opus agents closed about two more deals apiece and secured better prices than those with Haiku. Yet in post-market surveys, Haiku users rated their outcomes as fair, never guessing they were at a disadvantage.
Beyond proving that AI can manage real-world trades, the experiment highlighted a gap between perceived and actual performance. Even with identical starting budgets and clear rules, stronger models consistently edged out weaker ones. That suggests we’re not far from scenarios where behind-the-scenes AI agents drive everyday commerce—and where model choice could quietly shift who wins in a negotiation.