@paulg - RFK Jr. Defends 600%
@paulg on X Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. told a story about a Democratic senator who said a 600% drug price drop was mathematically impossible, and argued the math works both ways: $100 to $600 is a 600% rise, and $600 to $100 is a 600% savings. Trump agreed on camera, and the clip was posted on X with Paul Graham's commentary calling it a sign of who runs the government.
- RFK Jr. says a 600% price drop is possible by reversing a 600% increase, dismissing the senator's claim as a math error.
- Trump affirmed the point with a one-word "Right," which is the core of the clip.
- Paul Graham frames the exchange as evidence of the people now running the government, which is the post's real argument rather than the drug pricing itself.
The post is a tweet from Paul Graham (@paulg) that quotes a clip posted by @atrupar, a account that shares short video clips of politicians. The clip shows Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. describing an exchange with a Democratic senator, who he says claimed it was "mathematically impossible" for a drug price to drop by 600 percent. Kennedy's response was arithmetic: a $100 drug that rises to $600 is a 600 percent increase, and the same drug falling from $600 to $100 is a 600 percent savings. President Trump, in the clip, responds "Right."
Graham's own comment is the whole editorial stance. His tweet is a single line, "This is who's running the government," which frames the exchange as evidence of the people in charge not grasping basic math. The post doesn't offer a policy argument or cite the drug, the senator, or the context of the original exchange. It's a reaction to a clip, not a report.
The substance of the dispute is simple, and Kennedy is technically right about the percentage math. Going from $600 to $100 is a drop of $500, which is 83.3 percent of the original price, not 600 percent. A 600 percent drop from $600 would mean the price falls by $3,600, which is impossible for a price that starts at $600. Percentage decreases are capped at 100 percent, so the reasonable reading of "600 percent drop" is that Kennedy was describing the ratio of old to new prices, or was simply muddling the language. Kennedy's example works for increases, which can exceed 100 percent, but not for decreases. So the senator's "impossible" claim is closer to right than Kennedy's rebuttal suggests, and the clip is the sort of short exchange that is easy to misread out of context.